Total Pageviews
Popular Posts
-
I have neighbors who like to say, “Be careful” whenever I leave my house and head into Center City. The cautionary words annoy me. They anno...
-
Recently I reread the journals of Trappist monk, Thomas Merton, author of the best selling book, The Seven Story Mountain, written shortl...
-
THE BLACK MASS WITHIN VATICAN WALLS A recent US Catholic bishops meeting in Baltimore made a claim that there were far too few active Cath...
-
The Local Lens Published• Wed, Oct 23, 2013 By Thom Nickels When I ran into my friend Eric in Center City recently, he said he wanted ...
-
What does it mean to talk like a Philadelphian? Unfortunately, having a Philadelphia accent doesn’t carry the same cache as having a Boston,...
-
Tom Trento, Director of the Florida Security Council , was in Philadelphia last year to showcase the film, “ The Third Jihad ,” and to share...
-
In Philadelphia’s Morris House at 225 South 8th Street, I extend my hand to Julie Morris Disston, whom I am meeting for the first time. The ...
-
MATTHIAS BADLWIN WAS A VERY NICE MAN Will the City--and his so-called friends-- uphold that lega...
-
In 1973, my mother met Deep Throat superstar Linda Lovelace when the actress was in Philadelphia starring in a comedy called Pa...
-
THE LAST WORD (From ICON Magazine, February 2012) The neighborhood near Philad...
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
ILEANA WHO? A new book rediscovers a remarkable woman by Bruce Bawer (from Substack)
Ileana who?
A new book rediscovers a remarkable woman.
Bruce Bawer
Don’t judge every book by its cover – or by its title. The title of Thom Nickels’s new book, Ileana of Romania: Princess, Exile, and Mother Superior, might whet the appetites of some academics who specialize in certain subgenres of history, but the ordinary reader in search of a fun time might pass it by. Who the hell was Ileana? Who cares about Romania?
That would be a dumb move – because this is a fascinating read.
Indeed, there’s more riveting material in the introduction – in which Nickels limns the life stories of a variety of people who belong in roughly the same category as his protagonist – than there is in the main text of most books.
For example, Grand Duchess Elizabeth of Russia (1864-1918), daughter-in-law of Tsar Alexander II and sister of the last tsarina, Alexandra, became a nun to repent for her husband’s expulsion of 200,000 Jews from Russia, and was beaten to death by the Bolsheviks the day after they murdered the royal family in Yekaterinburg. Unceremoniously, her remains were thrown down a mine shaft.
Born in France and educated in England before he settled in America – at first as a student at Columbia University and a bohemian living on Perry Street in Greenwich Village, Thomas Merton (1915-68) later converted to Catholicism and became a Trappist monk at a monastery in Kentucky. His bestselling 1948 autobiography, The Seven Storey Mountain, described by Fulton J. Sheen as “a twentieth-century form of The Confessions of St. Augustine,” made him a celebrity and caused the number of young Catholic men choosing the monastic life to soar. As with the Grand Duchess Elizabeth, his death was inglorious: during a stay in Samutprakarn, 20 miles from Bangkok,he stepped out of his shower and was somehow electrocuted by an electric fan, which was found lying on top of his dead body.
Then there’s Bruce Chatwin (1940-89), the travel writer, who concealed from the public both that he was gay and that he had AIDS (his marriage to one Elizabeth Chanler was celibate), and who, when he wasn’t globetrotting to gather material for his books, hobnobbed with the likes of Christopher Isherwood, Edmund White, Jacqueline Onassis, Susan Sontag, and Jasper Johns. “Chatwin,” writes Nickels, called himself a nomad, writing that a nomad never has to worry about finding God or the finality of death, because the act of moving wards off all such concerns. He was planning to convert to Orthodox Christianity, and to give up nomadism for monasticism, when he succumbed to a horrible death at the hands of AIDS.
Grand Duchess Elizabeth, Thomas Merton, Bruce Chatwin: each of these life stories is engaging in and of itself, and taken together with the other material in the introduction (yes, there’s more, including a detour into Harry and Meghan), they do a surprisingly fine job of preparing us for Nickels’s portrait of someone whom we never heard of but who would have made a perfect fourth at a dinner party with them. Ileana (1909-91), the daughter of Marie of Romania (yes, the one who was immortalized in a four-line poem by Dorothy Parker), had six children with her first husband, Anton, the Archduke of Austria, and after being ordered to leave Romania after the Communist takeover, spent time in Switzerland and Argentina before settling down with her children in Massachusetts, where her visa issues were taken care of by Senator John F. Kennedy and where, with the proceeds from the sale of her crown, she was able to pay her debts, educate her children, and buy a house. In the ensuing years, she divorced Archduke Anton; had an 11-year marriage to a Romanian doctor and lawyer, which also ended in divorce; published a memoir; and went on lecture tours around the U.S. in which she made the case against Communism.
Then came the dramatic change. In 1961, Ileana entered an Orthodox monastery in France. Taking the name Mother Alexandra in 1967, she returned to the U.S., where she founded a monastery in Ellwood City, Pennsylvania. She remained there until her death in 1991.
Which raises the question: why did she do it? What was it about her that led her to join that small company of men and women, such as Grand Duchess Elizabeth, Thomas Merton, and Bruce Chatwin, who, having experienced fame and wealth and seen a good deal more of the world than most, felt motivated to turn their backs on it all and lead lives of ascetic contemplation?
Which is another way of expressing the question at the heart of all biographies: what made her tick?
Not that this is a straightforward biography – for which relief, much thanks. Monastic life may have much to be said for it, but the lack of a social life, combined with the rigid daily routines of group prayer and private contemplation, tends not to make for a riveting comprehensive biography. Instead of recounting Ileana’s life week by week or month by month, Nickels, in an attempt to gain as good as possible a sense of who she was and what led her into the monastic life, investigates the people and settings that made up her life – much in the way that the reporters in Citizen Kane seek out the key to the meaning of “Rosebud.”
He visits the monastery in Ellwood City and speaks about Ileana with the nuns there. He talks to the monks at a monastery in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, to which Ileana frequently went on retreats. He discusses Ileana at length with the woman who became her “soul mate,” and who claims that Ileana’s real father was Tsar Nicholas II. (Which, if history had turned out differently, could have raised major problems, given that Ileana “was a favorite playmate of the tsar’s son, Alexei, so much so that many at the time assumed the two would eventually marry.”)
Nickels digs out the report, in a 1930 issue of Time, of Ileana’s engagement to a sensitive, handsome young German-Polish count which was broken off because of his “effeminate practices” (as Time put it) – although it would appear that she really loved him, unlike either of the men whom she really married. And Nickels meets at length with Ileana’s only surviving son, who is extraordinarily willing to open up about his mother and the rest of his family.
What, then, to make of what Nickels calls Ileana’s “miracle of personal transfiguration” – her “reinvention of herself as a monastic after two marriages, the raising of a family, and an earlier life as a Romanian royal among the courts of Europe”? One thing of which this book reminds us quite powerfully – as, indeed, Citizen Kane does – is that other people’s lives, especially the lives of complex, accomplished people who are no longer among us, are mysteries. They’re collections of stories told by relatives, lovers, friends, enemies, colleagues, and acquaintances – and, often, in documents and recordings, by the people in question themselves. Many of those stories are surely apocryphal, most of them contradict others in important ways, and one or two of them, with any luck, may hold tantalizing clues to revealing secrets.
No, Nickels doesn’t presume to have worked out all the answers about Ileana. But he has done his research, placed his results before us, and given us no small amount of illuminating historical data. In short, he’s led us on a journey that’s well worth taking. For Ileana of Romania proves to have been an exemplary woman – and an enigma well worth pondering.



